1. Introduction
The “Agnipath Scheme,” launched by the Government of India in June 2022, represents a landmark reform in the recruitment process for the Indian Armed Forces. It seeks to change the way soldiers, airmen, and sailors are recruited, trained, and employed, with an overarching goal of making India’s military leaner, more youthful, and technologically adept. By introducing a short-term, contract-based recruitment system, the government aims to balance manpower needs with economic efficiency while addressing issues related to career planning and opportunities for young Indians.
This article provides an in-depth exploration of the Agnipath Scheme, including its objectives, the structure of the program, the recruitment process, advantages, disadvantages, and implications for India’s defense sector. It also explores the broader socio-economic impact of this policy on youth, society, and national security.
2. Background of the Agnipath Scheme
Keeping in view the recommendations of Kargil Committee after Kargil War 1999 Modi Govt took decision to implement it to create young lot to enhance efficiency of the fighting forces. Thereafter, India’s military recruitment system of Jawans has started based on this policy wef Jun 2022. Prior to this, it has traditionally involved long-term service commitments, with personnel serving anywhere between 15 to 30 years, depending on the service branch and role. While this model has ensured stability and a reservoir of experienced personnel, it has also led to challenges, such as:
1. Rising pension liabilities: With the Indian government paying pensions to millions of retired military personnel, defense pensions have become one of the largest components of India’s budget.
2. Aging military profile: The average age of soldiers, airmen, and sailors in the Indian Armed Forces was increasing. A relatively older force could potentially struggle with the physical and technological demands of modern warfare.
3. Limited job opportunities for the youth: The traditional recruitment process, with long-term service requirements, limited the entry of younger people into the armed forces.
In light of these challenges, the Agnipath Scheme was envisioned as a solution. The scheme is intended to introduce a younger and fitter profile to India’s military while also reducing pension costs and offering youth short-term opportunities in national service.
3. Objectives of the Agnipath Scheme
1. Reduce the average age of personnel: By recruiting youth for a fixed-term contract, the scheme aims to lower the average age of personnel in the armed forces to around 25 years.
2. Cost-effective military workforce: By reducing the number of personnel eligible for long-term pensions, the scheme will help ease India’s growing pension burden.
3. Attract youth: The scheme offers young Indians an opportunity to serve the country for a short period, gain valuable skills, and transition back into civilian life with enhanced career prospects.
4. Skill development and discipline: The scheme hopes to inculcate qualities of discipline, leadership, and skills among the youth, which can be leveraged in civilian life.
5. Enhance national security: The initiative will ensure a steady flow of motivated, fit, and well-trained personnel into the military, addressing the evolving challenges of modern warfare.
4. Structure of the Agnipath Scheme
Under the Agnipath Scheme, young individuals are recruited into the Indian Army, Navy, and Air Force under a short-term contract, with the recruits referred to as “Agniveers.” The key aspects of the scheme include:
1. Eligibility: Candidates between the ages of 17.5 to 21 years (later increased to 23 years for the initial recruitment phase due to the pandemic) are eligible to apply. This age bracket ensures that the candidates are physically fit and can meet the rigorous demands of military service.
2. Selection Process: The recruitment process for the Agnipath Scheme involves physical fitness tests, medical examinations, and a written test, similar to the traditional recruitment process for the armed forces.
3. Duration of Service: Agniveers are recruited for a tenure of four years. This includes both training and active service. After four years, only 25% of the recruits will be retained for long-term service, based on merit and the military’s requirements, while the remaining 75% will be demobilized.
4. Remuneration and Benefits: Agniveers receive a starting monthly salary of ₹30,000, which gradually increases during their tenure. In addition, they are entitled to risk and hardship allowances, insurance cover, and other benefits during their service period. Upon completion of four years, Agniveers who are not retained receive a “Seva Nidhi” package of around ₹11.71 lakhs, which is a tax-free lump sum amount, along with a certificate of skills and military experience.
5. Exit Plan: Those not retained after four years are provided with skill development certificates, opportunities for further education, and preferences in government jobs, paramilitary forces, and private sector employment.
5. Advantages of the Agnipath Scheme
The Agnipath Scheme has been touted as a transformative initiative for India’s defense forces, with several significant advantages:
1. Youthful Armed Forces
The average age of India’s armed forces is expected to decrease with the implementation of the Agnipath Scheme. Youthful recruits are physically fitter, more adaptable, and potentially more attuned to modern technology, which is increasingly critical in today’s military operations. A younger force can respond more effectively to the dynamic challenges of modern warfare.
2. Reduced Pension Liabilities
One of the most pressing issues in India’s defense budget is the growing pension liability. With an increasing number of retirees and a significant portion of the defense budget being allocated to pensions, the Agnipath Scheme offers a solution by reducing the number of personnel eligible for lifetime pensions. Only 25% of the Agniveers will be absorbed into long-term service, which means that the majority will not receive pensions, resulting in significant savings for the government.
3. Economic Benefits for Youth
The Agnipath Scheme provides young people with stable employment for four years, along with competitive remuneration, allowances, and a lump-sum payment at the end of their tenure. This short-term employment allows them to save money and develop skills, which can later be leveraged in civilian jobs. The government’s promise of skill development certificates and job preferences in paramilitary forces and other sectors enhances the employability of these individuals.
4. Focus on Skill Development
Agniveers receive training in discipline, physical fitness, leadership, and technical skills. These skills are invaluable not only for military service but also for civilian careers. By focusing on short-term skill development, the scheme helps create a pool of young, trained professionals who can contribute to various sectors of the economy after their military tenure.
5. Greater Career Flexibility
The Agnipath Scheme offers youth the chance to experience military life without committing to a lifelong career in the armed forces. This provides greater career flexibility, allowing individuals to serve the nation for four years and then pursue other opportunities, whether in higher education, public service, or the private sector.
6. Socio-Economic Upliftment
The scheme provides an opportunity for individuals from underprivileged backgrounds to gain employment, training, and financial independence. Agniveers from rural areas or economically weaker sections of society can benefit from stable earnings and acquire valuable life skills.
7. Discipline and Nation-Building
Military service instills values such as discipline, leadership, and patriotism. Even after their military tenure, Agniveers are expected to bring these values into their civilian lives, contributing to a more disciplined and resilient society. Moreover, the Agnipath Scheme aims to foster a sense of national pride and civic responsibility among the youth, promoting nation-building in the long run.
6. Disadvantages and Criticisms of the Agnipath Scheme
Despite the many advantages, the Agnipath Scheme has not been without its share of criticisms and concerns:
1. Job Insecurity
A major concern with the Agnipath Scheme is the job insecurity faced by Agniveers after completing their four-year tenure. With only 25% of the recruits being retained for long-term service, 75% of the Agniveers will need to find alternative employment after their military service. While the government has promised skill development and job preferences, many critics argue that these measures may not be sufficient to ensure stable post-service careers for all Agniveers.
2. Short-Term Service Tenure
The short tenure of four years may lead to a lack of continuity and experience in the armed forces. Critics argue that military training and experience cannot be fully developed in such a short period, especially when compared to the traditional long-term service model. This could impact the operational readiness and effectiveness of the armed forces, particularly in specialized roles that require more time to master.
3. Retention and Meritocracy
The process of selecting the 25% of Agniveers for long-term service is based on merit and performance. However, this selection process could lead to dissatisfaction among those who are not retained, especially if the criteria for retention are perceived as opaque or unfair. There is a risk that the retention process could become politicized or subject to favoritism, which would undermine the morale of Agniveers.
4. Impact on Military Cohesion or categorizes Soldiers into two Jawans and Agniveers.
Critics argue that the Agnipath Scheme could affect the camaraderie and cohesion within the armed forces. Traditional long-term service models allowed soldiers to build strong bonds and a sense of loyalty to their units over several decades. The frequent turnover of personnel under the Agnipath Scheme may weaken these bonds and affect unit cohesion. It also categorizes soldiers into two different categories in the forces (Agniveer and Jawan).
5. Post-Service Opportunities
While the government has promised skill development certificates and job preferences for Agniveers, the actual implementation of these measures remains to be seen. Critics have raised concerns about whether the private sector and paramilitary forces will absorb such a large number of demobilized personnel. Additionally, the skill sets acquired during military service may not always align with civilian job requirements, leading to a mismatch between expectations and opportunities.
6. Potential for Social Discontent
The prospect of large numbers of demobilized Agniveers entering the job market simultaneously could create challenges in terms of employment opportunities. If the government’s promises of job preferences and skill development do not materialize, there is a risk of social discontent among the demobilized Agniveers, particularly if they struggle to find stable employment after their military tenure.
7. Attrition and Waste of Training Resources
Investing in the training of Agniveers, only for 75% of them to leave after four years, may be seen as an inefficient use of resources. The armed forces will have to continually invest in recruiting and training new personnel, leading to potential wastage of time, effort, and money. Moreover, the loss of trained personnel after four years could impact the overall capability and operational readiness of the armed forces.
8. Impact on Family Life
The Agnipath Scheme may not provide the same level of long-term stability for the families of Agniveers as the traditional service model. With no guarantee of long-term employment, Agniveers and their families may face uncertainty regarding their future, particularly in terms of housing, education for children, and financial planning.
Conclusion
The Agnipath Scheme is a bold and transformative step in the modernization of India’s armed forces. It offers numerous advantages, such as reducing pension liabilities, providing opportunities for youth, and fostering a younger and fitter military profile. However, it also comes with its fair share of challenges, including concerns about job security, continuity of service, and post-service employment opportunities.
As with any major reform, the success of the Agnipath Scheme will depend on its implementation and the ability of the government to address the concerns raised by various stakeholders. If effectively managed, the scheme has the potential to not only strengthen India’s military capabilities but also contribute to the socio-economic development of the country by empowering the youth and fostering a spirit of discipline and patriotism.
In the long run, the Agnipath Scheme represents a significant shift in India’s approach to military recruitment, one that seeks to balance the needs of national security with economic efficiency and social development. Whether this new model will be sustainable and beneficial for India’s defence forces and society remains to be seen, but it undoubtedly marks a new chapter in the evolution of India’s armed forces.
However, there is an urgent need to Revisit/Review Agnipath scheme at the earliest, as it is dividing our soldiers into two categories, which may effect on the unity of our soldiers and also not suitable for technical arms like engineers ( Basic training = 09 Months, Swimming Training = 03 Months, Field Engineering Training = 06 Months, Bridging Training = 06 Months and Trade Training = 08 Months and Fresher Course =02 Months ), EME, Arty and Signal etc, where you need highly qualified technical expert soldiers to handle situations in the operations. For which these soldiers do more then two years of rigorous training to harness qualified grade to become professional, thereafter getting posted to the units. Now, how would you trained an Agniveer in 6 months for corps of engineer. Where you need a soldier fully trained to handle risky job for laying and breaching mine fields and providing service to built emergency bridges in the operations/ War scenarios.
Therefore, keeping in view the above, there is an urgent need to think over it and review on this policy, which is not suitable for all arms in the forces. Secondly, to avoid vertical division by categorizing (Agniveers and Jawans) between soldiers. However, 10% quota may be kept reserved separately under this scheme for Short Service (SS)/ Tour of Duty (ToD) in our armed forces, especially in the infantry units to fulfil the recommendation of the KARGIL Committee and rest of existing system must be continued until unless there is any special requirement.
Comments are closed.